Introduction                   

1. Summaries

1.1 One Paragraph

1.2 One Page

 

2. Family History

2.1 Parents

2.2 As a boy

2.3 Death in family

 

3. Demutualisation

3.1 Share offers

3.2 Halifax advice

3.3 Application

3.4 Stonewalling

3.5 Rejection

 

4. Appeal

4.1 Letters

4.2 Court Case

4.3 1999 AGM

4.4 2000 AGM

4.5 Case Review

4.6 Conclusion

 

5. Other Sites

5.1 UNHAV

5.2 ASA Complaints

5.3 FSO

5.4 Other Sites 

 

6. Press

6.1 Daily Telegraph

6.2 The Express

6.3 The Times

6.4 Other

 

7. Halifax/HBOS

7.1 About HBOS   

7.2 Group Sites

7.3 Personnel

7.4 Halifax Virus

7.5 Other

Halifax / HBOS Demutualisation Experience and Dispute

 

2. Family History

2.3 Death in family

It was at 10:20pm on the night of 8 January 1997 that I received the call that my father had passed away.  This was a great shock to me since although dad was not in perfect health we was not unwell. However, he was 90 years old, and had had a good life and had survived both world wars.

I am an accountant with a major multinational company and 31 December was the financial year-end and we had to finalise our accounts to a very aggressive timetable.  However, my employer was generous and gave me some time off, though not as much as I really needed.

On 9 January 1997, I travelled to Bognor Regis to sort our my father's affairs and then at approximately 11:45am on 10 January 1997 I went into the Halifax Building Society Branch in the High Street, Bognor Regis and sought advice on what I should do regarding my father's Halifax Building Society account.

I recall meeting a tall gentleman called Tim at the branch who was sitting at a desk in the open office area, and not behind the security screens. Tim from the Halifax advised me that: we must neither leave the account in my father's name nor should we close it since if we took either of these actions we would completely lose the share bonus.  I refer to "we" here because my brother and myself were joint executors in my father's will. 

I explained my brother's and my investment and mortgage situation and I was advised that the account should be renamed "John Perry and David Perry executors for L Perry". Tim explained that I would receive the highest share bonus and so the account should be renamed with my name appearing first.

As a result of this advice from the Halifax, I suggested to my brother that he need not actively act as an executor and so I applied for probate with myself as executor (since my name first on the account was the key for the share bonus). Halifax Building Society were later to inappropriately contend that as I was the executor, the account could not have consequently be renamed with my brother's name first and so my action disqualified us from the higher share bonus.

The fact was, as I was later to find out, I had been given incorrect advice and that if we had arranged for my brother's name to appear first on the passbook we would have received a greater share bonus.  Had we received this advice instead, my brother would of course have remained an executor. The decision on who would be the executor was made on 10 January 1997.

 

Page created on 26 June 2002, last updated: 22 October 2006 22:54

Please address any comments to: webmaster@halifaxsucks.co.uk

Hyperlinks will appear on the left border as the sections are completed.